Content created by Assistant Secretary for Legislation (ASL)
on
S. 4365, the “Veterinary Services to Improve Public Health in Rural Communities Act”
before
Senate Committee on Indian Affairs
July 10, 2024
Good afternoon Chair Schatz, Vice Chair Murkowski, and Members of the Committee. Thank you for the opportunity to provide testimony on an important legislative proposal before your Committee, and for your continued support of the Indian Health Service (IHS) and efforts from the Department of Health and Human Services to improve the health and well-being of American Indians and Alaska Natives (AI/AN). Your consideration today of S. 4365, the Veterinary Services to Improve Public Health in Rural Communities Act underscores that commitment to improving the quality of life in Indian Country.
I am Melanie Anne Egorin, the Assistant Secretary for Legislation (ASL) at the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS or Department). My office serves as the primary link between the Department and Congress. The Office of the ASL provides technical assistance on legislation to Members of Congress and their staff, facilitates informational briefings relating to Department programs to support policy development by Congress, and supports implementation of legislation passed by Congress. It is a pleasure to join the Committee again, as we work together to combat the public health challenges in tribal communities.
Background
The Department and the IHS agree that the increase of injuries and zoonotic disease spread by domesticated and wild animals in Indian Country represents a significant public health issue for tribal members in these rural communities. There are an estimated 70 million stray dogs and cats in the U.S., Tribal Lands, and territories, which contribute to traumatic events and injuries, zoonotic disease spread, and road traffic accidents. In recent years, free-roaming domestic animals have contributed to rabies outbreaks on Tribal lands, human deaths due to zoonotic diseases, and severe injury and death due to mauling.
The Department is working as a whole through diverse offices and mission areas to address the public health concerns related to zoonotic diseases, including rabies. The IHS already coordinates with and assists tribes with animal population control efforts to the extent practicable within its authorities. Additionally, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) and the Commissioned Corps of the United States Public Health Service (USPHS) help to lead Department efforts on the national surveillance of and education about rabies and other zoonotic diseases.
The IHS operates its mission, in partnership with AI/AN tribal communities, through a network of over 600 federal and tribal health facilities and 41 Urban Indian Organizations that are located across 37 states and provide health care services to approximately 2.87 million AI/AN people annually.
As you may know, appropriated funds to the IHS are used to provide health care to IHS-eligible AI/ANs –– the IHS’ defined service population. The Department and the IHS have worked hard to prioritize resources provided by Congress to ensure that patients have access to accessible – and affordable – quality care. The IHS works hard every day to ensure that limited resources are used wisely to ensure the greatest impact on its defined service population – from direct care services to sanitation and facilities construction, and health care facilities construction.
While it recognizes the importance of this emerging threat to Indian Country, the IHS has to balance its limited resources to deliver direct services to its defined population while combating a number of unique public health issues facing Indian Country, including the fentanyl and opioid crisis, the maternal mortality crisis, domestic and interpersonal violence, and high diabetes rates – to name a few. The Biden Harris Administration has advocated for additional resources to combat these growing threats in Indian Country and is committed to fighting to reduce health disparities impacting tribal members.
IHS Health Issues Related to Rabies Incidents in Rural Communities
The IHS has examined first-hand and heard directly from tribes about the real public health risk from the high rates of dog bite injuries in AI/AN communities. Over the past five years, there have been over 200 patients hospitalized from dog bite injuries or attacks at IHS clinics. The Navajo and Alaska Areas have had the highest number of bites requiring hospitalizations. During that same period, there were over 24,000 patients receiving ambulatory care from dog bites. The Navajo, Alaska, Great Plains, and Phoenix Areas have had the highest numbers of bite-related hospitalizations over the last 5 years.
The IHS has also heard from tribes – especially from those in Northern Alaska – who are desperate for assistance addressing the problem at its source. A multitude of challenges have created a perfect storm for risk of injury and disease spread from animals in especially rural areas. AI/ANs living on reservations often have little to no access to veterinary care. Gaps exist in the availability of free rabies vaccines to rural pets, resulting in a higher risk of rabies exposure in humans and animals. The lack of regular parasite control for pets in these areas has led to an increased risk of exposure to transmissible parasites to human beings. There is also a lack of access to veterinary spay-neuter surgery to reduce unplanned litters, which has led to an overpopulation of strays and abandoned dogs – thus increasing exposure to disease, parasite infestation, and dog bites.
The Indian Self-Determination and Education Assistance Act (ISDEAA) only authorizes contracts for certain programs prescribed by Congress. As the Committee knows, the IHS’ foundational purpose is to provide health care for AI/ANs. IHS’ authorizing statutes do not currently convey authority to carry out veterinary services. As IHS does not have the authority, there is no authority for a tribal health program to add the activity to its ISDEAA agreement.
HHS Public Health Surveillance, Education, and Partnerships
Within their authorities, the IHS, the CDC, and USPHS collaborate in careful coordination with other tribal, federal, state, county, and external partners to reduce the risk of zoonotic disease spread in Indian Country. The IHS Division of Environmental Health Services staff work on surveillance, training, and capacity building, and have been involved for decades with novel vector borne and zoonotic diseases not previously identified in Indian Country. This Division has implemented Hantavirus and Rocky Mountain Spotted Fever prevention strategies, conducted arbovirus surveillance and risk reduction strategies, and assisted tribal communities in the development of and adoption of lay vaccinator programs for rabies virus. It has also coordinated with outside partners to facilitate the delivery of spay, neuter, and rabies clinics for domestic dogs and cats. The U.S. Department of Agriculture’s Animal and Plant Inspection Service has collaborated with the IHS Division of Environmental Health Services at the local level as needed on zoonotic disease prevention or risk factor reduction projects.
The CDC collects data on domestic human rabies cases and conducts near real-time animal rabies surveillance in 54 jurisdictions, including Alaska, through the National Rabies Surveillance System. No Tribal communities have their own rabies laboratories and therefore they rely on relevant state laboratories for all testing. This may present a barrier to sample collection, testing, and reporting, which further obscures the burden of rabies in these communities. The CDC has conducted several surveillance evaluations to characterize rabies risks in Tribal Lands. In several high-risk Tribal communities in the southwestern U.S., rabies testing and reporting rates are up to 15-times lower compared to their adjacent non-Tribal communities.
An evaluation of the risk of rabies re-introduction into the U.S. found that the highest risk is in Tribal Lands where free roaming dog populations remain a major public health issue. It was found that the Navajo Nation is home to approximately 250,000 free roaming dogs, with many remaining unvaccinated against rabies. Rabies risk mapping performed by CDC, which considers road connectivity, urbanicity, and human-to-unvaccinated dog ratios found that up to 185,000 unvaccinated dogs likely reside in areas that could support and sustain dog-to-dog transmission of rabies. This highlights the realistic potential for reintroduction of dog-mediated rabies or spillover from local rabies reservoir wildlife in the Navajo Nation. These findings likely reflect similar vulnerabilities in other Tribal Lands across the United States.
S. 4365, Veterinary Services to Improve Public Health in Rural Communities Act
The Veterinary Services to Improve Public Health in Rural Communities Act would amend the Indian Health Care Improvement Act to combat zoonotic disease outbreaks and advance public health preparedness for Native communities, Alaska Native villages, or Indian reservations, including by providing spay and neuter services and vaccinations for animals.
S. 4365 would authorize the Secretary to expend funds for public health veterinary services to prevent and control zoonotic disease infection and transmission in IHS Service areas where the risk for disease occurrence in humans and wildlife is endemic. The bill would also enable the Secretary to deploy veterinary public health officers from USPHS to IHS Service areas to combat, prevent and control zoonotic disease infection and transmission in IHS Service areas where the risk is high.
The proposed legislation also mandates the Secretary and IHS to coordinate with the Director of the CDC, and the Secretary of Agriculture. Further, the bill would require the Secretary of HHS to submit to certain Committees in Congress on a biennial basis, a report on the use of funds, the assignment and deployment of veterinary public health officers from the USPHS, data related to the monitoring and disease surveillance of zoonotic diseases, and related services provided under the proposed legislation. Finally, S. 4365 would amend the Prepare for and Respond to Existing Viruses, Emerging New Threats, and Pandemics Act, to include the Director of the IHS, in the “One Health framework.”
Controlling the pet population would decrease the incidence of dog bites, which have caused an increase of injuries and deaths on Tribal Lands. This bill would potentially limit the incidence and spread of zoonotic diseases and also allow people to walk safely in their communities. The Department shares the same goal as the drafters – to combat zoonotic disease spreading in IHS Service areas and ensure that tribal members throughout Indian Country are protected with robust public health outbreak prevention. Like the bill’s drafters, the Department and IHS are looking to improve response to any zoonotic related disease and improve safety in tribal communities.
That being said, the bill, in its current form, does not include any additional resources for the Department to stand up a new program without compromising its efforts to provide direct care or combat other emergent public health challenges in Indian Country.
We look forward to continuing our work with Congress on improving the health of AI/AN populations including the issues related to this bill. As always, HHS welcomes the opportunity to provide technical assistance as requested by the Committee or its members.
Thank you again for the opportunity to testify today, and I am happy to answer any questions the Committee may have.